Bottom line up front: The best Givelify alternative depends on what's missing. For a full platform (giving + ChMS + app) → Tithely ($119/month). For lower transaction fees → Planning Center Giving (2% + $0.30). For enterprise giving + analytics → Pushpay. For text-giving focus → Kindrid.
Quick Comparison Table
| Alternative | Best For | Monthly Fee | Transaction Fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tithely | All-in-one: giving + ChMS + app | $0 / $119/mo | 2.9% + $0.30 |
| Planning Center Giving | Lower fees + PC integration | $14–$99/mo | 2% + $0.30 |
| Pushpay | Large churches, enterprise analytics | Quote only | Custom |
| Subsplash Giving | Media-heavy churches, branded app | $199+/mo | ~2.9% + $0.30 |
| Kindrid | Text-to-give focused churches | $99–$149/mo | Included |
| Faithlife Giving | Logos Bible integration users | $0/mo | 2.75% + $0.30 |
| Rock RMS | Free open-source, tech-savvy churches | $0 (self-hosted) | Via gateway |
1. Tithely — Best All-in-One Platform Alternative
The most direct Givelify alternative for churches that want more than a giving platform. Tithely's $119/month All Access bundle includes giving, Breeze ChMS, a custom church app, website builder, messaging, and events. If the reason you're leaving Givelify is "we need a ChMS," Tithely solves that without buying separate tools.
Transaction fees are identical to Givelify (2.9% + $0.30 for cards), but Tithely offers ACH at ~1% — significantly cheaper for churches with high bank transfer volume. The All Access bundle is also the only giving platform that bundles a branded church app at this price point.
Pros
- Bundles giving + ChMS + app + website for $119/mo
- ACH giving at ~1% (cheaper than Givelify cards)
- Month-to-month, cancel anytime
- Includes text-to-give (vs Givelify add-on)
- Strong multi-campus support
Cons
- Donor mobile UX rated below Givelify
- Same card rate as Givelify (no savings there)
- Bundled features you may not need
- $119/mo is significant for small churches
2. Planning Center Giving — Best for Lower Fees
The key reason to switch from Givelify to Planning Center Giving: lower transaction fees. At 2% + $0.30 versus Givelify's 2.9% + $0.30, a church with $10,000/month in card donations saves about $90/month — over $1,000/year. That savings easily covers the platform fee for most active congregations.
The second reason: if you're already using Planning Center for people, services, or volunteers, adding PC Giving creates a fully integrated system where giving history, donor records, and contribution statements all live in one place.
Pros
- Lower card rate: 2% + $0.30
- Lower ACH rate: 1% + $0.30
- Native PC People integration
- Excellent contribution statements
- Strong recurring giving management
Cons
- Monthly platform fee ($14–$99/mo)
- Best value only with other PC products
- Donor UX not as polished as Givelify
- Full Planning Center suite is expensive
3. Pushpay — Best for Enterprise Giving Analytics
Pushpay is the right Givelify alternative when your church has outgrown what Givelify's analytics can provide. For churches with $50,000+/month in giving, Pushpay's analytics — recurring giving optimization, lapse prediction, fund performance trends — justify the higher cost. Pushpay also delivers a custom branded mobile giving app, which Givelify doesn't offer.
Pros
- Enterprise analytics and donor insights
- Custom branded church app
- Dedicated account management
- Integrated with Church Community Builder ChMS
- Multi-campus giving management
Cons
- No public pricing — expensive
- Annual contracts typical
- Too expensive for small/mid churches
- Merger with CCB created product complexity
4. Subsplash Giving — Best for Media-Heavy Churches
Subsplash positions itself as the media + giving platform for churches that livestream, podcast, and want a premium branded church app experience. If your church is media-production focused — regular video, podcast episodes, streaming services — Subsplash bundles all of that with giving in a way neither Givelify nor Tithely match.
Pros
- Branded church app with streaming
- Podcast and media management
- In-app giving with branded experience
- Push notifications to congregation
Cons
- $199+/mo — expensive for giving alone
- Overkill if you don't need streaming/media
- No significant fee advantage over Givelify
5. Kindrid — Best for Text-to-Give
Kindrid's differentiator: donors give via a text message without downloading any app. For older congregations or in-service spontaneous giving moments, the frictionless text flow can capture donations that app-based platforms miss. It's particularly effective for first-time givers who aren't willing to download yet another app.
Pros
- No app download required for donors
- Simple text-to-give UX
- Flat monthly pricing (no per-transaction fees)
- Good for in-service giving moments
Cons
- $99–$149/mo is significant vs Givelify's $0
- Less feature-rich than full platforms
- No ChMS or member management
6. Faithlife Giving — Best for Logos Users
Faithlife Giving is part of the Faithlife/Logos ecosystem — including Proclaim presentation software and Faithlife Study Bible. For churches already using Logos or Proclaim, Faithlife Giving integrates natively. The transaction rate (2.75% + $0.30) is slightly lower than Givelify, and there's no monthly fee.
Pros
- $0/month platform fee
- Slightly lower card rate: 2.75% + $0.30
- Native Logos/Faithlife ecosystem integration
- Includes Proclaim integration for displays
Cons
- Best value only within Faithlife ecosystem
- Smaller user base than Givelify
- Donor UX not as refined as Givelify
7. Rock RMS — Best Free Option
Rock RMS can replace Givelify's giving functionality (and add a full ChMS) at zero software cost. The caveat is always the same: Rock requires technical staff. If you have that resource, Rock is the most capable free Givelify alternative by a wide margin.
Pros
- Completely free software
- Full ChMS + giving in one platform
- Fully customizable
- Active plugin ecosystem
Cons
- Requires technical staff to operate
- No official support
- Setup time is significant
AI Sermon Outlines, Devotionals & Church Content
While you're evaluating giving platforms, FaithStack's free AI tools help pastors prepare sermons, write devotionals, and create church bulletins in minutes — no subscription required.