Quick Verdict
Tithe.ly โ All-in-one church giving platform with a website builder, app creator, and giving tools. Pushpay โ Enterprise church giving and engagement platform for large and growing churches.
Feature Comparison
Pricing Comparison
Tithe.ly
2.9% + $0.30 per transaction (no monthly fee)
Giving โ 2.9% + $0.30/transaction
No monthly fee
Sites โ $79/mo
Website builder + giving
App โ $99/mo
Custom mobile app + giving
๐ก Free tier: No monthly fee โ pay only per transaction.
Pushpay
Custom pricing (typically $300+/mo)
Custom โ Contact for pricing
Based on giving volume and features
Pros & Cons
Tithe.ly
Pros
- No monthly fee for giving
- Easy to set up
- Great mobile giving UX
- Text-to-give is excellent
- Growing feature set
Cons
- Transaction fees add up
- Website builder is basic
- Support can be slow
Pushpay
Pros
- Best-in-class mobile giving UX
- Excellent analytics
- Strong church app
- Enterprise support
- Trusted by 14,000+ churches
Cons
- Expensive for small churches
- Pricing not transparent
- Long contract commitments
Who Should Choose Each?
Choose Tithe.ly ifโฆ
- Small to mid-size churches
- Churches new to digital giving
- Mobile-first congregations
- Your church is small or medium or large size
Choose Pushpay ifโฆ
- Large churches
- Churches with high giving volume
- Multi-site ministries
- Your church is large or mega size
The Bottom Line
Tithe.ly edges out as our top pick with a 4.5/5 rating and 1,234 verified reviews. It's especially strong for Small to mid-size churches and Churches new to digital giving.
That said, Pushpay is the better fit if Large churches. At Custom pricing (typically $300+/mo), it delivers solid value for the right church.